Shuga Pie is a must-stop if you are near Babylon in Long Island. Our long walk from the Babylon LIRR stop, around Belmont Lake State Park, led us in the past Shuga Pie, which was pretty lucky considering their shop is pretty removed from the retail traffic of the Main Streets of Long Island towns.
It was a rewarding detour as their cakes have a very homemade feel to them, which brings home so much nostalgia to a Pennsylvanian who grew up with Amish whoopie pies around the home, and they have so many flavors, the most difficult thing you will experience in the day is choosing which ones to consume. +++++ if you’re a vegan, like us, they offer multiple vegan Shuga Pies!!