Shuga Pie Shop in Babylon, Long Island – NY


Shuga Pie is a must-stop if you are near Babylon in Long Island. Our long walk from the Babylon LIRR stop, around Belmont Lake State Park, led us in the past Shuga Pie, which was pretty lucky considering their shop is pretty removed from the retail traffic of the Main Streets of Long Island towns.

It was a rewarding detour as their cakes have a very homemade feel to them, which brings home so much nostalgia to a Pennsylvanian who grew up with Amish whoopie pies around the home, and they have so many flavors, the most difficult thing you will experience in the day is choosing which ones to consume. +++++ if you’re a vegan, like us, they offer multiple vegan Shuga Pies!!

Maybe order a bunch and bring them to a potluck or family function, so you can chop them up + share and try many flavors.

My only disappointment is that they are not more accessible to us in Manhattan, but we heard rumor that they will be putting up a website soon that will allow for purchases and shipping of their delicious delights all over the country! Get excited!


  • Original (Madame Butterfly Cakes Buttercream)
  • Chocolate Cream
  • Lemon Cream
  • Blueberry Cream
  • Strawberry Cream
  • Raspberry Cream
  • Peach Cream
  • Mint Chocolate Chip
  • Chocolate Chocolate Chip
  • Vanilla Chocolate Chip
  • Cookies & Cream
  • Peanut Butter Cup
  • Snickers
  • Peanut Butter Cream
  • Caramel Cream
  • Mocha Chocolate Chip
  • Mocha
  • Irish Cream
  • Kahlua
  • Cream Cheese Filling
  • Chocolate Pudding
  • Vanilla Pudding
  • Vanilla Pastry Cream(Boston Cream Shuga Pie)
  • Chocolate Mousse



Cake Flavors:

  • Chocolate
  • Marble
  • Vanilla
  • Vanilla Chocolate Chip
  • Funfetti
  • Red Velvet
  • Lemon Coconut
  • Lemon
  • Orange
  • Carrot
  • Italian Cream Cake
  • Pina Colada
  • Guinness Chocolate
  • Banana
  • Apple Cake
  • Coconut
  • Almond

And a bonus – this business is run by very nice people who are passionate about their creations! They work so hard to ensure the customer will be happy and are glad to spend time telling you about the area and recommending other local haunts to check out. Thanks for being such lovely people.

All photos sources from Shuga Pies because we were too busy chatting with the nice owner to begin to consider documenting the sooooo many delicious Shuga Pie options we saw.